After an Internet search, I found a phone number and address for Macey Sign Co. (38 Mason Street, Worcester, MA 01610), a family run business since 1910. The Cotter’s Leather Goods sign was one of the first they were commissioned to paint according to the owner.
Wow! A company that’s been around since 1910 has definitely have to have some reputation. They would have to be one heck of a sign company to be around that long – with great customer service.